Who we are
What's new
Takeovers Code
Takeovers Act 1993
Panel Decisions
Exemptions
Publications
Articles & Addresses
Sitemap
Home

Search.

Disclaimer

Takeovers Panel
In this section

  • TAKEOVERS CODE (SPEIRS GROUP LIMITED) EXEMPTION NOTICE 2009
  •  

    2009/47


    Takeovers Code (Speirs Group Limited) Exemption Notice 2009

    Pursuant to section 45 of the Takeovers Act 1993, the Takeovers Panel gives the following notice (to which is appended a statement of reasons of the Takeovers Panel).

    Contents

    1 Title
    2 Application
    3 Expiry
    4 Interpretation
    5 Retrospective exemption from rule 6(1) of Code
    6 Condition of exemptions in clause 5
    7 Further retrospective exemption from rule 6(1) of Code
    8 Further retrospective exemption from rule 6(1) of Code
    9 Further retrospective exemption from rule 6(1) of Code
       


    Notice

    1
    Title
    This notice is the Takeovers Code (Speirs Group Limited) Exemption Notice 2009.

    2
    Application
    This notice applies to acts or omissions occurring on or after 1 July 2002.

    3
    Expiry
    This notice expires on the close of 30 June 2009.

    4
    Interpretation

    (1)
    In this notice, unless the context otherwise requires,-

    acquisition means an acquisition of voting securities described in the Schedule

    Act means the Takeovers Act 1993

    Code means the Takeovers Code under the Act

    exempted person means a person listed in the first column of the Schedule

    NZAX means the securities market operated by New Zealand Stock Exchange Limited under that name

    voting security means a voting security in Speirs Group Limited.


    (2)
    In this notice, a reference to a person increasing voting control is a reference to the person becoming the holder or controller of an increased percentage of the voting rights in Speirs Group Limited.

    (3)
    Any term or expression that is defined in the Act or the Code and used, but not defined, in this notice has the same meaning as in the Act or the Code.

    5
    Retrospective exemption from rule 6(1) of Code
    Each of the exempted persons is exempted from rule 6(1) of the Code in respect of any increase in that person's voting control as a result of each acquisition set out opposite to that person's name in the second column of the Schedule.

    6
    Condition of exemptions in clause 5
    The exemptions in clause 5 are subject to the condition that Richard Nelson Speirs and Donald Patterson Speirs comply with the written undertakings dated 30 January 2009 given by each of them to the Panel and accepted under section 31T of the Act.

    7
    Further retrospective exemption from rule 6(1) of Code
    Rebecca Speirs is exempted from rule 6(1) of the Code in respect of any increase in her voting control as a result of the transfer of 155 387 voting securities by David John Speirs in his personal capacity to her and David John Speirs in their capacity as trustees of the David and Rebecca Speirs Family Trust on or about 1 June 2004.

    8
    Further retrospective exemption from rule 6(1) of Code
    Kate Unsworth Speirs is exempted from rule 6(1) of the Code in respect of any increase in her voting control as a result of the following transfers of voting securities to her by Donald Patterson Speirs:
    (a)
    10 000 voting securities on or about 24 March 2006:

    (b)
    30 000 voting securities on or about 24 July 2008.


    9
    Further retrospective exemption from rule 6(1) of Code
    James Patterson Speirs is exempted from rule 6(1) of the Code in respect of any increase in his voting control as a result of the transfer of 30 000 voting securities to him by Donald Patterson Speirs on or about 24 July 2008.

    Schedule
    Acquisitions of voting securities
    Exempted person Acquisition of voting securities
      Number acquired   Date (on or about) acquired
    Richard Nelson Speirs and Donald Patterson Speirs (jointly) 10 000   15 July 2002
    Richard Nelson Speirs and Donald Patterson Speirs (jointly) 8 000   3 June 2003
    David John Speirs and Rebecca Speirs as trustees of the David and Rebecca Speirs Family Trust 16 001   20 May 2004
    Mary Glover Speirs 16 001   20 May 2004
    James Patterson Speirs 1 000   15 July 2002
    Nicola Jane Baldwin 1 000   15 July 2002
    Andrew David Nicholas 1 000   15 July 2002
    Anna Michelle Baldwin 1 000   15 July 2002
    Jeffrey Steven Nicholas 1 000   15 July 2002
    Kate Unsworth Speirs 1 000   15 July 2002
    Mark David Baldwin 1 000   15 July 2002
    Matthew John Nicholas 1 000   15 July 2002
    James Patterson Speirs 1 000   4 July 2003
    Nicola Jane Baldwin 1 000   4 July 2003
    Andrew David Nicholas 1 000   4 July 2003
    Anna Michelle Baldwin 1 000   4 July 2003
    Jeffrey Steven Nicholas 1 000   4 July 2003
    Kate Unsworth Speirs 1 000   4 July 2003
    Mark David Baldwin 1 000   4 July 2003
    Matthew John Nicholas 1 000   4 July 2003




    Dated at Auckland this 10th day of March 2009.

    The Common Seal of the Takeovers Panel was affixed in the presence of:

    David Jones
    Chairman


    Statement of reasons

    This notice applies to acts or omissions occurring on or after 1 July 2002 and expires on 30 June 2009.

    The Takeovers Panel (the Panel) has granted retrospective exemptions from rule 6(1) of the Takeovers Code (the Code) to—

    • each member of the Speirs family listed in the first column of the Schedule in respect of any increase in that person's voting control as a result of each acquisition of shares in Speirs Group Limited set out opposite to that person's name in the second column of the Schedule:
    • Rebecca Speirs in respect of a transfer of Speirs Group Limited shares to her and David John Speirs, in their capacity as trustees, on 1 June 2004:
    • Kate Unsworth Speirs in respect of transfers of Speirs Group Limited shares to her on 24 March 2006 and 24 July 2008:
    • James Patterson Speirs in respect of transfers of Speirs Group Limited shares to him by Donald Patterson Speirs on 24 July 2008.

    Between June 2002 and August 2008 a number of transactions occurred that resulted in members of the Speirs family increasing their control percentage in Speirs Group Limited. These transactions included the acquisition of voting securities on-market, the transfer of voting securities from individuals to a family trust, and intra-family transfers.

    At the time of the transactions (both before and after) Richard Nelson Speirs and Donald Patterson Speirs each held, either individually or together, more than 20% of the total voting rights in Speirs Group Limited.

    It is accepted that there are grounds on which it could be asserted that 1 or more of the Speirs family members involved in the transactions were associates of each other for the purposes of the Code at the time of the transactions.

    On 30 January 2009, Richard Nelson Speirs and Donald Patterson Speirs each provided an enforceable undertaking to the Panel that—

    • each of them, together with the other, would, between them, dispose of to 1 or more persons (each a third party) who is not an associate (as that term is defined in the Code) of any family member listed in the Schedule of the undertaking, 66,002 shares in Speirs Group Limited (the subject shares) on or before 31 March 2009:
    • pending completion of the disposition of the legal title to all the subject shares to a third party under the undertaking, each of them, together with the other, would, between them, not exercise the voting rights attaching to 66,002 Speirs Group Limited shares or appoint any proxy in respect of 66,002 Speirs Group Limited shares:
    • within 48 hours of completion of the disposition of the subject shares in accordance with the undertaking, each of them, together with the other, would provide the Panel with written notification of the following particulars of that disposition:
      • the number of Speirs Group Limited shares disposed of:
      • the identity of any third party to whom any of the subject shares are transferred (if known):
      • the consideration for the disposition of any of the subject shares to any third party (if any):
      • the particulars of any agreements between a third party and the person disposing of the subject shares in relation to the transaction:
    • each of them, together with the other, would make an announcement to New Zealand Stock Exchange Limited by 31 January 2009, in a form approved by the Panel, explaining the circumstances of the transactions, and the undertaking given to the Panel.

    The Panel considers that it is appropriate and consistent with the objectives of the Code to grant the exemptions to the Speirs family members named in the Schedule because—

    • the Panel has accepted enforceable undertakings from Richard Nelson Speirs and Donald Patterson Speirs under which they have undertaken that they will dispose of a number of securities equivalent to the total number acquired by the exempted persons in apparent breach of the Code. Under the undertakings, the securities must be disposed of to persons not associated with any of the exempted persons:
    • it is a condition of the exemption that the enforceable undertakings must be complied with:
    • the apparent breaches of the Code appear to have been inadvertent.

    The Panel considers that it is appropriate and consistent with the objectives of the Code to grant each of the exemptions to Rebecca Speirs, Kate Unsworth Speirs, and James Patterson Speirs because—

    • the shareholders of the company are not disadvantaged by not being able to vote on the transfers because the transfers were intra-family transfers that did not increase the overall holdings of the Speirs family in Speirs Group Limited and were of a nature that the Panel would have exempted from rule 6, without the requirement of shareholder approval, had such an exemption been applied for prior to the transfer:
    • the apparent breaches of the Code appear to have been inadvertent.


    Issued under the authority of the Acts and Regulations Publication Act 1989.
    Date of notification in Gazette:
    This notice is administered by the Takeovers Panel.